Now I know better than to buy into everything I watch on television, but I also realize that there are elements of truth in those news stories. After the feature was over, I googled "Amanda Knox" and was bombarded with the different links.
Hmmmm... Where do I begin?
After spending an hour or two on the world wide web, I wasn't sure what to think. It's hard to decipher truth from spin. I attempted to channel the spirits of my former political science and communications professors at DePaul who taught me to be more suspicious of the media. Examining the coverage and looking for the truth was like trying to trim the fat out of a pork roast before you cook it --- time consuming and there will always be some left after all your efforts.
Sigh.
So what did I learn?
- Many Europeans have negative stereotypes of Americans; many Americans have negative stereotypes of Europeans.
- The European and American media continue to feed the ideas we have of each other. Thanks a lot.
- The justice system standards in Italy are different than what we have here in the U.S. Jury selection, preventing jury from being exposed to news coverage, evidence requirements, etc.
- It is everyone's desire to punish the person(s) responsible for the horrific slaying of Meredith Kercher.
- It is possible that two innocent people will spend 26 years in an Italian prison.
As an observer so far removed from the situation, I don't think justice has been served. Maybe I've been watching too much CSI or Bones or reading too many Patricia Cornwell books, but I think the prosecutor needs more evidence to convict Amanda and Raffaele. It should be more than just having a questionable reputation created by the media.
At one time or another, we have all been victims of gossip. Out of jealousy or fear, people make a judgment about you and then they do a horrible thing --- they sell the idea to anyone who will listen. They don't stop to explore the root of their issues with you. They form an opinion and start talking. The worst part is that people DO listen. They proliferate these negative ideas about you by passing it on, perhaps adding their own two cents. And people listen and pass it on. And so on and so on...
Then there you are --- YOU HAVE A BAD REPUTATION.
This has happened to me a few times. I'm friendly, easygoing, and outgoing. I've been told I'm "cute" (although most days I don't feel that way). Being short in stature, people tend to feel comfortable around me, sometimes enough to give me an affectionate hug or noogie on occasion. I try to be friends with everyone. "You attract more flies with honey," so goes the cliche. Well, it's true. I have enjoyed popularity in the workplace - not out of being a politician - but because I'm nice. That's it.
When you get attention, there are some people that get jealous. They desire the same attention. They don't realize that they can have it too if they are just nicer and maybe smile every now and then. Seriously, it's that easy. Instead of putting their efforts into something positive like that or working on overcoming their insecurities, they figure that it's easier to make people turn on you by spreading rumours of your supposed ulterior motives and illicit affairs. At one point, there were rumours of me sleeping with four different men.
Seriously??? Uh, like that could ever happen. Who has the time? Ha ha. Just kidding.
So the point is that, in my opinion, the people in Italy have made the easy choice of believing Amanda is truly the monster that the European media has made her out to be. They want to find a killer. They have negative stereotypes of Americans. The media has put two and two together and it all makes sense to them. I'm pretty sure this made an impact on the jurors.
On the flip side, the American media has done a great job of touting her innocence. It might be true; maybe not. Who can be completely sure? We've all seen Snapped. Can they be accused of taking sides as well? Sure they can. The American people want to believe that she is innocent, after all she's one of us.
So what do I think? After taking in the coverage from American and European news sources, then reading this inteview with novelist Doug Preston, who has personal experience with the procescutor Judge Giuliano Mignini, I think Amanda and Raffaele are innocent and that the real killer is already in jail.
Amanda's family plans on appealing the decision. It will be interesting to see how this story unfolds. For the sake of all involved, my hope is that the truth is revealed and justice is served.
* * * * *
On a side note, here's a way to show your support for Amanda:
Amanda Knox Defense Fund
